The Telephone Game – When Good Ideas Go Sideways

I love that education is constantly searching for better. There is no ‘finish line’ or box-to-check to say that “We’ve made it.” It’s really the thing that makes K-12 education so exciting and motivating — we can always get better:

  • Better ways to engage students.
  • Better ways to support learning.
  • Better ways to prepare young people for a future that seems to evolve more quickly every year.

In that pursuit, we often turn to research. We read books, attend conferences, listen to podcasts, and look for evidence that can help inform our next steps. That’s a good thing.

Implementing a Plan takes more than Having a Positive Disposition

But, it’s also a concern.

Sometimes the challenge isn’t finding good ideas — sometimes the challenge is what happens after we find them.

Some intriguing research appears. Educators become excited. Professional learning sessions are developed. Schools begin implementing new approaches.

But, sometimes — somewhere along the way — the idea becomes simplified. The complexity fades. The critical nuance of why something works disappears.

Before long, what remains is often a version of the original idea that is far removed from what researchers, educators, or even the earliest adopters intended.

The Telephone Game: An activity where players pass a whispered message around a circle of people, usually resulting in a very different message at the end of the line.

Nobody sets out to create this outcome. In fact, it often happens because people care deeply about improvement. We want to help students — to get better. We want to act.

Yet meaningful change requires more than action. It requires understanding.

I’ve come to believe that one of the most important questions educational leaders can ask is not “What should we do?“, but instead ask questions such as:

  • “Why does this work?”
  • “How do I adapt the research to fit my circumstances?”
  • “What do I need to understand before determining next steps?”

When we understand the WHY behind an initiative, we’re less likely to become attached to a particular strategy and more likely to remain focused on the outcome it was designed to achieve.

The best schools I’ve encountered aren’t the ones chasing every new idea. They’re the ones that remain curious, asking the thoughtful questions — the ones digging a little deeper to better understand something before leaping to implementation.

Perhaps that’s the lesson for all of us:

  • Innovation matters
  • Research matters
  • But, understanding matters most.

Because when we lose sight of the WHY, even good ideas can end up as another initiative that goes sideways — just like a story in the Telephone Game.

The First Lesson is the Most Important One

Before we teach content, we teach belonging — about the importance of children seeing themselves reflected in relationships, culture and words in our schools. Every September when students arrive — some for the first time, some returning for their 13th year — we ask ourselves a question:

Do students feel like they belong?

The research is clear — when students experience belonging — engagement rises, absenteeism falls, and achievement nudges ahead. Studies show that while a school district can help shape the overall sense of community, it is the adults who have daily contact with students that make them feel like they belong. And it is mostly teachers who provide those personal conditions necessary for the positive feelings of belonging at school.

Teachers make it all work.

It Begins in Kindergarten

Kindergarten — that place where the magic begins. One of the early lessons for our newest students is also one of the most important — and our newest students learn the lesson through their play:

How do we interact with others? How do we learn to accept our differences and celebrate our uniqueness? How do we see our worth and value?

It begins by finding ways to honour all people — including those who have been here on this land for thousands of years. For me as Superintendent, the work we do on understanding and incorporating Indigenous ways of knowing is paramount to the mission we have in public education. The local W̱SÁNEĆ First Nation community has a fabulously rich culture, language and traditions that helps our district to ground our work — from Indigenizing the curriculum, building cultural competencies in our staff, introducing all K-students to the local language, and most importantly, building understanding, belonging and trust on a daily basis.

The Land, The History, The Ways of Being

In Saanich, teaching about belonging often begins with teaching about place — about the ancestral territory of the W̱SÁNEĆ people — stewards of these lands and waters since time immemorial. We are fortunate to have a strong, respectful and collaborative working relationship with the local First Nation which builds a broad community understanding about the history and culture of those who have been here for thousands of years. We are helping to reinvigorate the local and unique SENĆOŦEN language — from district‑wide Kindergarten lessons to programs at a number of our schools. School‑based Indigenous Education teachers support cultural and academic learning, and this past year, community partners celebrated a new, locally developed, district course on W̱SÁNEĆ culture and history — born from student voice and designed with significant contributions from local elders and knowledge keepers.

We also learn through story on the land — using local W̱SÁNEĆ stories and place‑based learning to strengthen oral language and connection. The Indigenous Education page on our district website is filled with links to a wide variety of items including local art that can be loaned, learning resource kits, online virtual resources and a host of other items that provide a rich fabric of opportunities to truly embed Indigenous ways of knowing and being into classroom lessons. The monthly Indigenous Education bulletin highlights new and timely resources for teachers at all levels and subject areas in our system.

Celebrating the History and Contributions of Indigenous Peoples Across Canada

Belonging Isn’t a Program

Belonging isn’t a program or a class — it’s a practice. When we know names, notice strengths, honour identities, and communicate clearly, students show up with courage, engagement and excitement.

And, when we recognize the people who have been here for thousands of years, we help build a community that is respectful and inclusive.

We build belonging.

Happy National Indigenous History Month everyone!

Confidence Isn’t a Synonym for Competence

Have you ever watched someone speak with absolute certainty about a topic, and you knew that they really had no clue about what they were talking about?

It’s uncomfortable, isn’t it?

We have all likely been that person at some point — where our confidence exceeds our ability. What is that strange gap between confidence and competence? That’s the Dunning-Kruger Effect — and it shows up more often than we think, especially in the workplace. For a few people, it can be a daily event.

Dunning-Kruger Effect: A cognitive bias where people with low competence in a skill tend to overestimate their own abilities and knowledge in that area. This lack of metacognitive awareness prevents them from accurately assessing their own performance, while high performers often underestimate their abilities.

It’s not arrogance — it’s a lack of self-awareness. And ironically, the more skilled you actually become, the more you realize how much you really don’t know. It’s a humbling paradox: ignorance breeds confidence, while knowledge breeds humility.

In the workplace, this can manifest in subtle but impactful ways:

Confidence does not Always Equal Competence
  • Take the new manager who’s just stepped into a leadership role. They’ve read a few books, maybe taken a course or two, and suddenly they’re convinced they know how to lead a team. But leadership isn’t theoretical –it’s relational. Without emotional intelligence, listening skills, and the ability to navigate conflict, that over confidence can quickly erode trust.
  • In politics, a new leader speaks from a place of confidence yet includes statistics and events that are not true or highly exaggerated to make their point. Their presence presents itself as arrogance — yet it’s uninformed arrogance. Being familiar with the topic, you soon lose trust in the leader. You question their integrity, intentions and ability.
  • Or the school district leader, who’s just attended a one-day workshop on a new pedagogical approach to language instruction. They return to their school district, energized, ready to overhaul their system. But, without deeper understanding or support, the implementation falters. Staff are confused, students are frustrated, outcomes may drop, and the leader feels disillusioned. The intent was good, but the execution lacked depth.

Understand this effect isn’t meant to shame anyone. It’s about recognizing a pattern — and learning from it.

The real danger of the Dunning-Kruger Effect isn’t ignorance itself — it’s the illusion of knowledge. When we think we know more than we do, we stop asking questions. We stop listening. And that’s when growth stalls. Arrogance takes over and learning stops.

So how do we move forward as an organization?

NORMALIZE NOT KNOWING

  • In a culture that rewards certainty, admitting “I don’t know” can feel risky. But it’s actually a sign of calm wisdom. The most competent leaders I know are the ones who ask the most questions. They’re not afraid to look foolish by not knowing, because they know that learning is messy — and worth it.

BUILD FEEDBACK-RICH ENVIRONMENTS

  • Whether it’s in a classroom, the boardroom, or a team meeting, feedback helps us calibrate our self-perception. It’s not about criticism — it’s about clarity. When we invite others to reflect back on what they see, we gain insight into our blind spots. And that’s where real growth begins.

INVEST IN REFLECTION

  • Think about a time you were sure of something and later realized you were completely off base. What led you to that conclusion? What did you miss? Reflection isn’t about beating ourselves up — it’s about building self-awareness. Self-awareness is the antidote to the Dunning-Kruger Effect.

LEAD WITH HUMILITY

  • Humility isn’t weakness — it’s strength. It’s the quiet confidence that comes from knowing your limits and being open to learning. When leaders model humility, they create space for others to do the same. And that’s when teams thrive.

The Dunning-Kruger Effect isn’t a flaw — it’s a feature of how our brains work. But when we understand it, and pay attention to opportunities when it might happen, we can move from unconscious incompetence to conscious growth.

So, stop pretending to know when you don’t … admit when you don’t know something … and look for those opportunities to gain the knowledge you’re missing.

Be genuine … Be transparent … Be humble … and seek knowledge.

Why wouldn’t we want to do that?

(This post was inspired by the author prompting AI, however, the majority of the writing is the author’s own work.)